How Satellites Can Help resolve Covid learning crisis
[Music]
hi tedx viewers
i want to be talking to you today on
something which is close to
all our hearts and something which
decides our
future that is provisioning
quality education for all as envisaged
in the sdg
four for example the importance of
education
cannot be overstated it
levels the playing field taking
any religion or color
or social status out of the picture
it is a means to improve your livelihood
to yourself to your family and to your
community
but the sad reality is there are
lots of children maybe a billion who are
out of school
and even who are in the school are
faring well below the grade in which
they are
and not getting themselves equipped
for the job opportunities in the 21st
century quality education
is something which requires
conceptual understanding
and this means that you have to for
example
learn to read very early
so that you can later read to learn
world bank recently has introduced a
concept of learning poverty
what it means is at the age of 10 a
child should be able to
read a small paragraph in
any language and comprehend it
they found that in most countries more
than 50 percent of the children
do not meet this criteria so much so
they have now revised the sdg4 target
to mean that by 2030 we want to half the
number of such children so unless
we sort of start early
you cannot address these issues because
the foundations are laid
when they are very young and if the
foundation is weak
all their future learning whatever the
best of the technology techniques that
we use
would be of no avail and
if they do not get the right skill set
then they will be more of a demographic
disaster
than the demographic dividend which will
be if
they are skilled and are able to be
employed properly
contributing to the gdp
even before covid there was a
very large variation in the learning
outcomes
if you look at the normal curve you will
see that it’s wide
and one of the important objectives is
to narrow this
variance or reduce the width and be able
to move it
to higher values for the learning
outcome that the mean should increase
and the variance should decrease
come covered the entire situation became
worse schools got closed so on the lower
end of the normal curve
you ended up with a large hump
especially for the low resource areas
where they did not have the right
opportunities so those people
are falling so far behind that one is
very worried
what will happen to them are they not
going to be
unemployed or underemployed and cause a
lot of problems with the society
unless we act now and when you want to
do this
you would want to make use of
such a technology which would help us
to tide over this and be in a position
to turn this crisis to an opportunity
but for doing that first let us quickly
understand what is the process
of conceptual understanding what it
means is that
the concepts which are in my head i
would like to transfer it
to maybe five more maybe two hundred
maybe a thousand or maybe two million
and when i want to do this first you
have learning materials which we call
content
then it has to be properly brought to
the learner that is the connectivity
then on a device if it’s the digital
content is going to be consumed it’s
going to be the learning process
of the student it has to be properly
guided in such a way
that you also assess for his learning
so that you under and come back with
what is needed
to make him understand the concepts
thoroughly
so this process is something which
happens again and again
for every topic every lesson every
subject
but then you must look at a solution
from the needs a demand driven solution
will always be more sustainable so what
do we need
we need quality contents we need a
way to transfer it to the right places
at the right time
and we should have the way of consuming
the content
and have a way to assess the way the
learning is happening
so all these are going to be properly
done there
when you look at the content for example
there is no depth of content
today in fact we have ended up with lot
more content
and so the problem is one of plenty so
one has to decide
what is the best which i should choose
what will fit in with my
audience and how do i get it ready
for that consumption you know that is
the easier part
now when it comes to connectivity almost
everyone
is going with a belief that when you say
digital education
it means that you must provision a
broadband
internet connectivity to the schools to
the teachers
to the students and so on they think
that this particular provisioning
is a must in order to provide digital
education whether on the other hand
digital education digital contents
and transforming it into their heads is
something which is a different process
in fact when i discuss this with even
my friends i feel like galileo galilei
when he proposed a heliocentric model
where there’s so much opposition because
the problems
argue that until the time when we
achieve
this kind of a universal internet
connectivity
we have to go with some stop gap
arrangements but then
all governments all institutions are
funding heavily
to make sure that everybody finally will
be
connected to the internet and that
would probably be the time when there
will no more discussion on
quality education because education
would be achieved when access is there
but when you go really and analyze the
correlation between
access and the learning outcomes
is not strong in fact sometimes it will
be even negatively correlated you have a
lot of access
you end up with a lot of distractions in
fact i met with lots of kids from
very well to do families and i’ve talked
to their parents
and they will think oh i bought them the
latest gadget and the
kind of very high broadband connectivity
thinking that they will all be used for
their educational process
but when i later find out their kind of
learning
levels there’s wide variations so it’s
not directly
correlated at all and therefore assuming
that
access to internet is the
access to education is like saying that
the
most intelligent man in a community is a
librarian because he has access to all
the books
see if a ladder is placed on the wrong
wall however fast you claim you’ll never
reach the
destination see what is good for
one kind of traffic may not be the right
one right communication link
for some other traffic for example now
for working from home which is so
important during the covet conditions
or for emails or for social media
interactions etc you certainly need
internet connectivity
and if this latest
technologies for example mega
constellations of
low earth orbiting satellites all these
would make sure
that this service would be available
everywhere on the globe
including in the remotest village so
it’ll be very good
but when it comes to education
especially the early education
you find that it’s so much schedule
based
there is a curriculum the syllabus you
have to follow lesson by lesson today is
lesson one
in english and you would want to teach
some poetry
and that poem will be taught in school
one or school two or school three or
school thousand
all of them follow the same syllabus and
therefore there’s a lot of commonality
in what needs to go on that day if
there’s a match
exam every student would like to pass
question papers
answered revisions and so on so
therefore if there’s a commonality
you must look for a broadcast solution
and for the broadcast solution
one of the standard things that we can
do is to have a satellite broadcast
because satellites are inherently
broadcast media
and therefore it will be always the best
leveler
whatever goes to one very highly urban
conglomerate
would be the same which goes to the
remoters rural
community and that is very very
important for example
about 40 years ago when i was just
living in bangalore in india i found
that there was a time when we didn’t
have any
television coverage at all then it
started with one channel which was
relayed from two different cities and
all that
within couple of years the entire thing
changed like anything because satellites
came in
and they had capacity to provide what is
called
direct to home dth service which made
sure
that whatever program i watch in the
five-star comfort in a hotel is the same
that as home in a slum area
would want to get he may not have a roof
but he will have a roof antenna
to receive this so a similar kind of a
transformation can happen in terms of
delivery of
education so the advantage of such a
scheme is twofold
one is the fact that we are pushing the
content the pushing
means that there is no traffic
congestion and the sender decides
what goes in to the user devices
when it should go how long it should
reside you can purge it also
all these can be controlled from one
single central end that’s one great
advantage
the other thing is that there is one too
many when you’re talking about
the same thing goes to everybody
therefore
the research on what should be the good
one can be done
once and for all so that means the best
teacher
best learning materials is available to
everybody
the best super experts
are available for sort of giving clues
ex and teaching aids to the teachers
all over so the skill variation of the
teachers can be taken care
of by having such a link you know
synchronously
and like this what happens is if finally
the assessment part
is also important i’m going to touch
upon that is something which can
also be done in such a manner
that that information can go to each and
every location so that’s a great
advantage
but then the question comes what is the
space segment do you have the satellites
available for this
broadcast satellites like dth we talked
about direct
home here dtp a direct person kind of
satellite
but we don’t have to wait for that maybe
we can put in a payload
which is a hosted payload or simply what
we can do
today we have the dth services all over
and we can
directly use that service look at the
picture i’ve shown a schematic
where i’ve shown the television programs
the contents are aggregated on the
teleport and
uplink and the satellite brings it down
to each and every
small dish in the homes same way on the
same channel
we can encapsulate the digital contents
it can be files it can be live stream
any ip stream
can be sent along this on the same path
and now same dish in that home or in the
school
can receive it but then when it comes
down you take that signal
and then you look at only the digital
content for the education
store it in a server locally and then
make it available on a local hotspot
to the devices of the individuals bring
your own device that’s what i’ve shown
there
so the important companies of course
that local server also because that acts
as a digital library where the
downloaded contents or what is delivered
you know we don’t use download
we don’t use online we take on-site we
have this
particular content which is available
for browsing
by the children with no risk of
any distraction no need to check for
which link is better and all because we
have made the choice
at the sending end so this scheme is
something which is doable right away
and therefore this delivery of content
via the satellite itself cannot achieve
the quality education because that would
require
hand holding and guidance which has to
be done by the teachers as i was telling
you the teacher
skill levels are widely variable and
therefore rather than giving them
a summer course of training and all it
doesn’t seem to work
just in time lesson by lesson on that
this kind of topic
you give them the right kind of
additional tips
cheat sheets which they will remember
from their short-term memory and be able
to conduct the class better
the pupils listen better
they respect the teacher now more and
the positive spiral sets in
and this kind of a way the teachers also
improve their subject matter knowledge
the pedagogy and all that
and also what happens assessment is very
important which has to be done by the
teacher
today the teacher is overloaded so
probably he just gives you a
multiple choice question and just takes
it and gives it back
but it’s much more than that because we
believe
no one is mediocre and everyone can
learn
if the way they want to learn you have
to find out
and for that purpose one shoe fits all
won’t work
and therefore the feedback is required
as to what the student needs
and that the teacher only can do but in
the close out of this
schools the best time to try new
technologies
where even local volunteers can help and
once all the data is collected
you can certainly make machine learning
and then have a kind of techniques
to make sure that the assessment
component is a continuous assessment
because that is very important for the
demographic dividend because everyone
has to finally be brought up engaged
educated
and be able to contribute to the society
of course india has done lots of things
in this regard right from 1975 with a
satellite instructional television
experiment where
villages were given developmental
communication
then exclusive satellite for education
hadoos act
but now for example if you look at dta
channels they’ve as many as 32 channels
called swim prabha
which are all on different subject
matters but usually they are all
for higher classes and they are
delivered on a tv and all that which is
not the best medium for
like this kind of education but we can
use that channel
and ride on that and be able to conduct
more of such educational content
delivery to remote locations in
addressable form it’s a directed
delivery
address directly to those particular
locations and this is immediately
available
and therefore such a scheme is as
important like
the nutritional schemes which make sure
that the physical stunting
does not take place for the children
same way
if you keep the children properly
conceptually learned with the
fundamental knowledge
that will reduce the mental stunting
also
and then what we notice is this
particular education is therefore
delivered
right at the doorsteps of each and every
individual
and no more waiting for internet
connectivity no more waiting for
smartphones with some of these people in
the poorer sections of society
have you know sold their properties in
order to buy a smartphone for the child
thinking that the only way they can
contribute to the education of the child
but now that’s all gone i think we can
turn
this crisis to our advantage and
make sure that education gets the reform
that it badly needs
we will have quality because we are
making sure
that this is going all the way
assessment inclusive
uniformity because satellite delivery is
all
the places are treated equally and
therefore we will achieve
uniform quality education for all
and meet the goals of u.n bodies thank
you