What prosecutors and incarcerated people can learn from each other Jarrell Daniels
When I look in the mirror today,
I see a justice and education scholar
at Columbia University,
a youth mentor, an activist
and a future New York state senator.
(Cheering)
I see all of that
and a man who spent
a quarter of his life in state prison –
six years, to be exact,
starting as a teenager on Rikers Island
for an act that nearly cost
a man his life.
But what got me from there to here
wasn’t the punishment I faced
as a teenager in adult prison
or the harshness of our legal system.
Instead, it was a learning
environment of a classroom
that introduced me to something
I didn’t think was possible for me
or our justice system as a whole.
A few weeks before my release on parole,
a counselor encouraged me to enroll
in a new college course
being offered in the prison.
It was called Inside Criminal Justice.
That seems pretty
straightforward, though, right?
Well, it turns out,
the class would be made up
of eight incarcerated men
and eight assistant district attorneys.
Columbia University psychology
professor Geraldine Downey
and Manhattan Assistant DA Lucy Lang
co-taught the course,
and it was the first of its kind.
I can honestly say
this wasn’t how I imagined
starting college.
My mind was blown from day one.
I assumed all the prosecutors
in the room would be white.
But I remember walking into the room
on the first day of class
and seeing three black prosecutors
and thinking to myself,
“Wow, being a black prosecutor –
that’s a thing!”
(Laughter)
By the end of the first session,
I was all in.
In fact, a few weeks after my release,
I found myself doing something
I prayed I wouldn’t.
I walked right back into prison.
But thankfully, this time
it was just as a student,
to join my fellow classmates.
And this time,
I got to go home when class was over.
In the next session, we talked
about what had brought each of us
to this point of our lives
and into the classroom together.
I eventually got comfortable enough
to reveal my truth to everyone in the room
about where I came from.
I talked about how my sisters and I
watched our mother suffer years of abuse
at the hands of our stepfather,
escaping, only to find ourselves
living in a shelter.
I talked about how I swore
an oath to my family
to keep them safe.
I even explained how I didn’t feel
like a teenager at 13,
but more like a soldier on a mission.
And like any soldier,
this meant carrying an emotional
burden on my shoulders,
and I hate to say it,
but a gun on my waist.
And just a few days
after my 17th birthday,
that mission completely failed.
As my sister and I were walking
to the laundromat,
a crowd stopped in front of us.
Two girls out of nowhere
attacked my sister.
Still confused about what was happening,
I tried to pull one girl away,
and just as I did, I felt something
brush across my face.
With my adrenaline rushing,
I didn’t realize a man
had leaped out of the crowd and cut me.
As I felt warm blood ooze down my face,
and watching him raise
his knife toward me again,
I turned to defend myself
and pulled that gun from my waistband
and squeezed the trigger.
Thankfully, he didn’t lose
his life that day.
My hands shaking and heart racing,
I was paralyzed in fear.
From that moment,
I felt regret that would never leave me.
I learned later on they attacked my sister
in a case of mistaken identity,
thinking she was someone else.
It was terrifying,
but clear that I wasn’t trained,
nor was I qualified,
to be the soldier
that I thought I needed to be.
But in my neighborhood,
I only felt safe carrying a weapon.
Now, back in the classroom,
after hearing my story,
the prosecutors could tell
I never wanted to hurt anyone.
I just wanted us to make it home.
I could literally see the gradual change
in each of their faces
as they heard story after story
from the other incarcerated
men in the room.
Stories that have trapped many of us
within the vicious cycle of incarceration,
that most haven’t been able
to break free of.
And sure – there are people
who commit terrible crimes.
But the stories
of these individuals' lives
before they commit those acts
were the kinds of stories
these prosecutors had never heard.
And when it was their turn
to speak – the prosecutors –
I was surprised, too.
They weren’t emotionless
drones or robocops,
preprogrammed to send people to prison.
They were sons and daughters,
brothers and sisters.
But most of all, they were good students.
They were ambitious and motivated.
And they believed that they could use
the power of law to protect people.
They were on a mission
that I could definitely understand.
Midway through the course,
Nick, a fellow incarcerated student,
poured out his concern
that the prosecutors were tiptoeing
around the racial bias and discrimination
within our criminal justice system.
Now, if you’ve ever been to prison,
you would know it’s impossible
to talk about justice reform
without talking about race.
So we silently cheered for Nick
and were eager to hear
the prosecutors' response.
And no, I don’t remember who spoke first,
but when Chauncey Parker,
a senior prosecutor, agreed with Nick
and said he was committed to ending
the mass incarceration of people of color,
I believed him.
And I knew we were headed
in the right direction.
We now started to move as a team.
We started exploring new possibilities
and uncovering truths
about our justice system
and how real change
happens for us.
For me, it wasn’t the mandatory
programs inside of the prison.
Instead, it was listening
to the advice of elders –
men who have been sentenced to spend
the rest of their lives in prison.
These men helped me reframe
my mindset around manhood.
And they instilled in me
all of their aspirations and goals,
in the hopes that I would never
return to prison,
and that I would serve
as their ambassador to the free world.
As I talked, I could see the lights
turning on for one prosecutor,
who said something I thought was obvious:
that I had transformed
despite my incarceration
and not because of it.
It was clear these prosecutors
hadn’t thought much about
what happens to us
after they win a conviction.
But through the simple process
of sitting in a classroom,
these lawyers started to see
that keeping us locked up
didn’t benefit our community
or us.
Toward the end of the course,
the prosecutors were excited,
as we talked about our plans
for life after being released.
But they hadn’t realized
how rough it was actually going to be.
I can literally still see the shock
on one of the junior
ADA’s face when it hit her:
the temporary ID given to us
with our freedom
displayed that we were
just released from prison.
She hadn’t imagined how many barriers
this would create for us
as we reenter society.
But I could also see her genuine empathy
for the choice we had to make
between coming home to a bed in a shelter
or a couch in a relative’s
overcrowded apartment.
What we learned in the class
worked its way into concrete
policy recommendations.
We presented our proposals
to the state Department
of Corrections commissioner
and to the Manhattan DA,
at our graduation in a packed
Columbia auditorium.
As a team,
I couldn’t have imagined
a more memorable way
to conclude our eight weeks together.
And just 10 months
after coming home from prison,
I again found myself in a strange room,
invited by the commissioner of NYPD
to share my perspective
at a policing summit.
And while speaking,
I recognized a familiar face
in the audience.
It was the attorney
who prosecuted my case.
Seeing him,
I thought about our days in the courtroom
seven years earlier,
as I listened to him recommend
a long prison sentence,
as if my young life was meaningless
and had no potential.
But this time,
the circumstances were different.
I shook off my thoughts
and walked over to shake his hand.
He looked happy to see me.
Surprised, but happy.
He acknowledged how proud he was
about being in that room with me,
and we began a conversation
about working together
to improve the conditions
of our community.
And so today,
I carry all of these experiences with me,
as I develop the Justice Ambassadors
Youth Council at Columbia University,
bringing young New Yorkers – some
who have already spent time locked up
and others who are still
enrolled in high school –
together with city officials.
And in this classroom,
everyone will brainstorm ideas
about improving the lives
of our city’s most vulnerable youth
before they get tried
within the criminal justice system.
This is possible if we do the work.
Our society and justice system
has convinced us
that we can lock up our problems
and punish our way
out of social challenges.
But that’s not real.
Imagine with me for a second
a future where no one can become
a prosecutor,
a judge,
a cop
or even a parole officer
without first sitting in a classroom
to learn from and connect with
the very people whose lives
will be in their hands.
I’m doing my part to promote
the power of conversations
and the need for collaborations.
It is through education
that we will arrive at a truth
that is inclusive and unites us all
in the pursuit of justice.
For me, it was a brand-new conversation
and a new kind of classroom
that showed me how both my mindset
and our criminal justice system
could be transformed.
They say the truth shall set you free.
But I believe
it’s education
and communication.
Thank you.
(Applause)