Rebalancing the Song Economy
i’d like to start
with a quote but it’s very embarrassing
because i don’t know where it comes from
but it’s very well put and it goes like
this
copyright is designed not only to
provide
fairness for authors but also to enhance
the quality
of life within a society by promoting
the progress of science art and culture
in other words the concept of making it
economically
feasible for creators to create
is now globally recognized as a social
imperative
i have very few memories of writing
lyrics to songs
but there is a particular one from long
ago that i do remember
i was lying on my stomach on a bed in a
small guest room
with a writing pad in front of me in the
master
bedroom next door my then wife agneta
was sleeping undisturbed
the music was playing in my head
so no need for speakers not even
headphones
a melody that still lacks words is
virgin territory upon which
a lyricist must tread lightly
some of the time the final words on the
page
are the result of hard work
deep thought and the intuition that a
songwriter
must learn to trust but sometimes
extraordinary things happen
closed curtains are suddenly drawn and
the melody speaks to you
it starts to conjure up images
and even sequences of events
all you have to do is write it down
write down what you witnessed a song
can come to its creator in bits and
pieces
but when it once in a while appears out
of thin air
in its entirety it seems to suggest
it had already lingered there god knows
how long
perhaps impatiently waiting to be
plucked down
by someone with a keen and sensitive ear
as if it needed the right vessel to flow
through
from the realm of ideas all the way down
to earth
i was deliriously happy when i had
finished
at that moment i was grateful for music
itself
for the sheer existence of this
elusive undefinable phenomenon
that seems to ignore our brains and go
straight to our hearts i wanted to sing
it out loud
but it was two o’clock in the morning
and even in my euphoria i had the good
sense
not to wake the woman who was to sing my
words the next day
if benny anderson and i had written that
song today
you might not have gotten to hear it it
could have been
just another lost stream about 80
000 new songs uploaded to streaming
services
every single day the competition
today is fierce much fiercer than it was
back in 1977 and even if our song
had been clicked very often by spotify
subscribers chances are slim that the
royalties would have paid
anyone’s rent so what i want to talk to
you about
today is how i see the changes
in the song economy using my
perspective of what it was like to be a
songwriter when the music industry
was simpler and perhaps more predictable
these days everything is tracked by our
data
and data from streaming tells us
that listeners much more often click
their favorite song
than their favorite artist on a
streaming service
sometimes they’re not even sure who it
is they’re listening to
if it’s a playlist for example so if
we’re paying more attention to the song
though what about the songwriter
songwriters have been forced into the
back seat
and i would even say bungle into the
trunk
my concern is that songwriters are at
risk of becoming invisible victims
of the change that is taking place
the music business is now a song economy
yet the creators of the songs that fuel
it
get the smallest slice of the pie how
did that happen
i am not for one moment about to suggest
that we
should turn back the clock which you
may have suspected from an old pop star
but what’s happened in the last decade
has the potential to be incredibly
positive for songwriters
now instead i’m going to describe the
unintended consequences
of the streaming revolution how they are
reshaping the lives of songwriters
and then i will present some proposals
for how the impact of these unintended
consequences
can be addressed it has never been a
better time to be writing and making
making music
anyone today has the potential to find a
global audience
and if they so choose they can even try
to do that
on their own without a record label or
music publisher
a whole music software industry is
emerging
serving the needs of a new generation of
artists and songwriters
streaming has enabled this new music
paradigm once the pandemic stopped
live music in 2020
many artists realized that they couldn’t
pay their bills on streaming alone
some have moved back in with our parents
and
others are driving ubers to make ends
meet
previously streaming had more or less
been promotion
for their tours and live appearances by
far
providing most of their revenue it’s
funny but it was exactly the opposite
for abba
in the 70s we hardly toured at all
and when we did we lost money
but i mean the touring was supposed to
be promotion for the albums
that it didn’t matter and i can’t recall
that we ever complained about the size
of our royalties
which the artists during the pandemic
have done bitterly when streaming
royalties suddenly were the only
source of income
if this is the impact on artists i
thought
welcome to the world of songwriters
most professional songwriters don’t tour
they don’t sell t-shirts or other
merchandise
they rely on the song itself but even
that seems to be changing
because the song has evolved in response
to streaming
and it’s increasingly common for record
labels to get
large teams of songwriters to work
together
creating almost genetically modified
hits
songs are written and structured in ways
that are optimized
for the algorithms that streaming
services use
to decide what music you and i listen to
some research has been done to suggest
that these days
a billboard top 10 hit has on average
five songwriters not one or two but
five and sometimes even ten and on top
of this
they’re having to write more songs and
more quickly simply to keep up with the
insatiable demand for
new music that streaming creates
after abba had won the eurovision song
contest in 1974
with waterloo royalties suddenly came
pouring in and benny and i could afford
to write songs
full time nine to five
i’ve made such a huge difference
we could afford to throw away 95 percent
of what we wrote
and just keep the very very best we we
learned how to recognize
garbage and that’s essential if you want
to get good at your craft
royalties simply gave us time and
creative freedom needless to say
you will have neither if you’re in a
hurry and
someone is breathing down your neck all
the time
the industrial approach to songwriting
is making it harder for many songwriters
to build sustainable careers
those that are successful are very
successful
but those in the layers below who used
to be able to make
living from songwritings are really
suffering
they are becoming parts of a system
that they serve more than it serves them
and here are three key pain points
firstly streaming services typically
pay out about four times more for the
recording than they do
the composition which means a streaming
income
is even smaller for songwriters than it
is for artists
it’s a legacy from the past when
recordings
and the packaging of physical products
were very expensive
so a larger share for recording was
justified
but that has changed but the change has
not yet been
reflected in the division of royalties
secondly even the way that streaming
services
pay royalties is problematic
a listener’s monthly 9.99 subscription
goes into a central pot which then
gets divided by the total number of
streams that month that decides the
value of one stream or listen
this means that you if you have streamed
arnold johnson’s gesture if you have
done that
50 times in the past month and the
neighbor’s teenage daughter has streamed
justin bieber 5 000 times
only a small fraction of your 99 will go
to honor jansen nothing wrong with
justin bieber but
how does that reward your favorite
artist
and thirdly bad metadata
is a big problem metadata being
the relevant information about a song
and it’s recording
very often recordings are injected into
a streaming service
without accurate data the name of the
writer is missing for instance
that means that the streaming service
doesn’t know
where to send the royalties and the
money is put
in a so-called black box just sits there
recently 20 streaming services
distributed
424 million dollars
to a u.s non-profit organization
which is supposed to try and find the
rightful
recipients of all that money it will
take years if they ever find them
the combination of all these issues and
others
are creating a perfect storm for
songwriters
over the last decade i’ve watched this
situation
get progressively worse and during the
past five years
i’ve been engaged in projects that
aim to do something about it so how can
i help
well first of all
i have you all here today listening to
me
and that’s of course what i want to do
to raise awareness
but i want to do more than just raise
awareness of the issues i also want to
help the industry identify solutions
and here are a few suggestions
out of many
one fan centric royalties
in order to ensure that all songwriters
get paid
fairly i suggest that streaming services
allocate their royalty payments based on
the behavior of individual listeners
the individual description should be
divided by the number of songs the
individual listen
listener has played during a month
that gives each song a value if the
subscription is 9.99
and the listener has played 10
honor johnson again songs that month
each song has the value of .99 almost a
dollar
and that’s the amount that will be paid
to
on a jansen under the current system
you can be sure that arne would get
the value of .00 something dollars
so this fan centric approach to
royalties will bring
much needed fairness and can build on
the important starts made by diesel and
soundcloud
but perhaps the simplest and most
effective way
to improve streaming royalties
would be for streaming services to
increase how much they charge
streaming pricing has been stuck at
ridiculous 9.99 for more than a decade
meanwhile netflix seems to increase its
pricing every week
research shows that subscribers will pay
more
9.99 could quite easily become 11.99
perhaps even 12.99
and thirdly the tedious but
absolutely necessary registration
wherever the 80 000 new songs per day
make their entry into the music industry
there should be user-friendly
registration portals
to make sure that relevant information
about the work is captured early
this would diminish the problem with
black boxes and conflicts
in my view it is an obligation for
collecting societies
who collect creators royalties at source
to modernize and to adapt their
technology to the digital age
i know it’s easy for me to stand here
and in front of you
and reel off a list of suggestions
for the industry much easier than making
these changes happen
but change does need to happen and soon
crucially this change needs to be
brought about by the music
industry as a whole each part
working together the song and the
songwriter
fuel everything from the recording
through to live performances even a
t-shirt would not sell if the band
hadn’t good
songs i have created memories
with some of those songs from the
everly brothers and then the beatles
elton john and many more
songs that sometimes would surprise me
with a stab of envy
quickly washed away by their sheer
beauty and the inspiration that they
gave me
i know what they mean and what they
meant to me
i’ve often wondered what would we be
without music less human i’m i’m
convinced of that
if we couldn’t hear music then what else
would we be deaf to
but we never seem to think about that
even though music is
all around us all of the time
this is the moment for the entire music
industry
to invest in supporting what is without
a doubt its most valuable asset
far too many songwriters out there are
suffering in this
creaking system solutions like those
that i have outlined
could help rebalance the song economy
so that more songwriters and their
listeners
will be able to lean back and say in all
honesty
exactly what i said in the song that i
was talking about
in the beginning thank you for the music