How to be an antiracist teacher in a mostly white school Taryn Coe

[Music]

think for yourself

the teacher might be wrong as a little

girl

these are the eight words i saw placed

prominently above the chalkboard in my

mother’s classroom

i knew even then that i wanted to follow

in my mom’s footsteps and become

a public high school teacher years later

in 2004 when i was setting up my first

classroom at the seattle high school

where i currently teach

i chose to display those same words i

knew that i wanted my classroom to be a

space where students felt valued

where they realized that their ideas

were just as important as mine

the school at which i teach is the

widest public high school

in the city of seattle with 75 percent

of its students identifying as caucasian

i remember my mom talking about the

challenges of incorporating anti-racist

practices

at the high school where she taught with

a mostly white student body and almost

entirely white staff

it was easy for many of the teachers and

students at the school to see racism as

someone else’s problem i have become

convinced

that it is especially important for

white educators in majority white

schools

to ensure that their students and

colleagues are educated

about racism because we as white people

are not experiencing the pervasive daily

racism

that people of color experience this is

compounded by the fact that white

students who grow up living in mostly

white neighborhoods and attending mostly

white schools

often have very little direct contact

with people of color

this means that unless their parents and

teachers actively choose to discuss

race and racism with the young people in

their lives our students will grow up

with a woefully incomplete understanding

of race and racism this leads to a lack

of knowledge about the profound

impact that race has on the power

structures in our country

and a lack of understanding as to how

people of different races are treated

in our country it is our job as

educators

especially white educators and majority

white schools

to ensure that our students have the

opportunity to learn about

how and why racism is still a problem so

that they can be part of working

toward a more just society especially in

a majority white school

students and teachers of color should

not be expected to educate white

students or white teachers about racism

i have worked with students and teachers

of color who feel like they are expected

to be experts on race and racism

or to be leading the fight against

racism in their schools

if and when the topic of racism comes up

in a classroom where there are few

students of color

well-intentioned white teachers

sometimes make these students the focus

of the discussion

share your experience with us so that we

can understand

rather than expecting white students to

do the hard work of acknowledging and

understanding

how white people benefit from systemic

racism in our country

i have talked with students of color who

already feel isolated and misunderstood

in majority white schools

these feelings are compounded when these

students are expected to lead the way

for their white peers

we as white teachers need to be

proactive about ensuring we have created

an environment where students of color

feel

safe respected and included rather than

spotlighted or isolated along the same

lines we as white educators should work

to ensure that we are not expecting our

colleagues of color

to shoulder the burden of anti-racist

work while shying away from the work

ourselves i try to remind myself that

it’s okay to be uncomfortable and i

acknowledge that there are times where i

will say or do the wrong thing when i’m

discussing racism with students

the important thing is that i’m willing

to own my mistakes

and i’m committed to learning and

growing from these mistakes

so that i can do better next time in

these instances i’m reminded of

holocaust survivor elie wiesel’s words

regarding neutrality and oppression

he says we must always take sides

neutrality helps the oppressor never the

victim

silence encourages the tormentor never

the tormented if i as a white educator

remain neutral

about racism i am not remaining neutral

at all

my silence is helping to perpetuate

racism

next i’d like to share some concrete

steps i’ve taken in my own life to

become a more actively anti-racist

educator i started by doing some work to

learn more about the history of racism

in our country

and to understand more about my own

identity and privilege as a white person

this included attending lecture series

about the history of racism

at a local university and reading widely

from leaders in the field of race and

equity work

i started a book group with other

educators and a discussion group with

other parents who are interested in

learning more about race and racism

for me it helped to do this initial work

in spaces that were distinct from my

school life

i was still able to talk about how and

why this learning was important for my

growth as a teacher

but it also encouraged me to think about

how and why this learning was important

for my growth as a parent

and a human being this has allowed the

anti-racist work i do as a teacher to be

more authentic

because it’s grounded in how i see my

purpose in the greater world

as an english language arts teacher i

had long been a proponent of teaching a

diverse set of texts

but i now knew that teaching diverse

authors alone is not

anti-racist i needed to go a step

further and make my teaching about race

more explicitly

to this end i crafted a new unit called

race in america

around three core texts that i was

already teaching monster by walter dean

myers

the absolutely true diary of a part-time

indian by sherman alexie

and american-born chinese by gene lewen

yang

each of these novels features a teenage

protagonist of color and is written by

an author of color

which provides a clear entry point for

students to begin exploring issues of

race and racism

i asked students to track the character

development of their novel’s protagonist

especially with regard to how the

character’s racial identity

impacts their development we supplement

students reading of these novels with a

wide variety of shorter texts that

explore issues of race and racism

and students draw connections between

the experiences of the novel’s

protagonists

and the issues that emerge in the

supplemental texts such as white

privilege

white supremacy implicit bias

microaggressions

since starting this unit i’ve expanded

the core novel options to include texts

by female authors of color

featuring female protagonists of color

this side of home

by renee watson and the hate u give by

angie thomas

in the case of the hate u give students

were the driving force behind the

addition of this text

this provides students with a concrete

way for them to work on turning their

study of race and racism

into action it’s important that students

are provided with an opportunity to take

meaningful steps toward fighting racism

as learning about racism can sometimes

leave students feeling hopeless

or overwhelmed helping students to see

their own

power and encouraging them to recognize

their ability to make a positive

difference in the world

can alleviate some of the cynicism and

frustration students feel

as they deepen their understanding of

the long history of institutional racism

and white supremacy in our country this

brings me to my final recommendation

about anti-racist work and education and

it also brings me back to where this

talk began

the most important expectation in my

classroom think

for yourself the teacher might be wrong

this idea is especially important as a

white teacher doing anti-racist work in

a predominantly white school

students especially students of color

need to feel safe calling me out when i

make mistakes

they need to know that they can hold me

accountable and point out to me when the

impact of my behavior is harmful

it is also critical that we as teachers

invite students to be active

participants in our anti-racist work

student learning should not be confined

to the classroom

students need to be provided the

opportunity to take an active role in

anti-racist activism in their school

and in the greater community i hope that

you will consider the ways in which you

can continue to deepen and expand

anti-racist teaching in your own

practice doing so is not easy

and we will make mistakes along the way

but if we remain

silent in the face of racism we are

complicit in perpetuating a system that

is harmful to our students

as elie wiesel said we must always take

sides given the choice let us take the

side of truth let us take the side of

inclusion

let us take the side of justice

because equity matters

you

[音乐]

自己想想,

小时候老师可能错了

这是我看到的八个字,

放在妈妈教室的黑板上方显眼的位置,

即使那时我就知道我想

追随妈妈的脚步,成为

一所公立高中 老师 多年后

的 2004 年,当我在我目前

任教的西雅图高中建立我的第一间教室时,

我选择了同样的词语

和我一样重要

我教的学校是西雅图市

最广泛的公立高中

,有 75

% 的学生认为是白种人

我记得我妈妈谈到在高中

纳入反种族主义做法的挑战

在那里,她

与大多数白人学生和几乎

完全是白人的教职员工一起教书,学校

的许多老师和

学生很容易将种族主义视为

别人的问题 我已经

确信,对于

大多数白人学校的白人教育工作者来说,

确保他们的学生和

同事接受

有关种族主义的教育尤为重要,因为我们作为白人

并没有经历有色人种所经历的普遍的日常

种族主义

,这种情况更加

复杂 事实上,

白人社区长大并就读于

白人学校的白人学生

通常很少

与有色人种直接接触,

这意味着除非他们的父母和

老师积极选择

与他们所在地区的年轻人讨论种族和种族主义。

我们的学生将在

对种族和种族主义的不完全

理解的情况下长大

在我们国家,作为

教育工作者,

尤其是白人教育工作者,这是我们的工作 s 和大多数

白人学校,

以确保我们的学生有

机会了解

种族主义如何以及为什么仍然是一个问题,

以便他们能够成为努力

实现更加公正的社会的一部分,特别是

在大多数白人学校中

,有色人种的学生和教师

不应该 期望对白人

学生或白人教师进行

种族主义教育

种族主义

出现在几乎没有有色人种学生的教室里

善意的白人教师

有时会让这些学生成为讨论的焦点

与我们分享您的经验,以便我们

能够理解

而不是期望白人学生

努力承认和

了解白人如何从

我们国家的系统性种族主义中受益

我与已经感到孤立的有色人种学生交谈过

在大多数白人学校中

被教育和误解 当这些

学生被期望

为他们的白人同龄人带路时,这些感觉更加复杂

我们作为白人教师需要

积极主动地确保我们创造

了一个有色人种学生

感到

安全受到尊重和包容的环境,而不是

我们作为白人教育工作者应该

努力确保我们不期望我们

的有色人种同事

承担反种族主义工作的负担,

同时

自己回避工作 不舒服,我

承认在与学生讨论种族主义

时,有时我会说错话或做错事

,重要的是我愿意承认

自己的错误,

并致力于

从这些错误中学习和成长

这样我下次在这些情况下可以做得更好,

我想起了

大屠杀幸存者埃利威塞尔

关于中立和压迫的话

他说我们必须始终站在

立场中立帮助压迫者永远不会

受害者

沉默鼓励折磨者永远不要

折磨如果我作为一名白人教育者

对种族主义保持中立我根本不会保持中立

我的沉默有助于使种族主义永存

下一步我想要 为了分享

我在自己的生活中为

成为一名更积极的反种族主义

教育者而采取的一些具体步骤,我首先做了一些工作来

更多地了解我们国家的种族主义历史,

并更多地了解我自己

作为 一位白人,

其中包括在当地大学参加

关于种族主义历史的系列讲座,

并广泛阅读

种族和平等工作领域的领导者

我与其他

教育工作者建立了一个读书小组,并与

其他有兴趣

学习的父母建立了一个讨论小组 对我来说,更多关于种族和种族主义

的信息有助于

在与我的学校生活不同的空间中完成这项初步工作,

我仍然能够谈论如何 以及

为什么这种学习对我

作为一名教师的成长很重要,

但它也鼓励我思考

这种学习如何以及为什么

对我作为父母

和一个人的成长很重要这使得

我作为一名教师能够开展反种族主义工作

更真实,

因为它基于我如何看待我

作为一名英语语言艺术老师在更广阔的世界中的目标我

一直支持教授

多样化的文本,

但我现在知道单独教授不同的

作者并不是

反种族主义 为此,我需要

更进一步,让我的种族教学

更加

明确我围绕三个核心文本制作了一个名为“美国种族”的新单元

,我

已经在教 walter dean

myers

的怪物绝对真实的兼职日记

Sherman alexie 的《印度人》

和gene lewen yang 的美国出生的中国

人 这些小说中的每一部都以有色人种的青少年为

主角,并且由

有色人种的作者撰写,

这为 stu 提供了一个明确的切入点

开始探索

种族和种族主义问题

我要求学生跟踪

他们小说主人公的性格发展,

特别是关于

角色的种族身份如何

影响他们的发展 我们

用各种探索问题的较短文本来补充学生阅读这些小说的

内容 种族和种族主义

和学生

在小说主角的经历

和补充文本中出现的问题之间建立联系,

例如白人

特权

白人至上隐性偏见

微侵略

自从开始这个单元以来,我已经扩展

了核心小说选项,包括

女性的文本 有色人种的作者描绘

了有色人种的女性主角,

蕾妮·沃特森(renee watson)和安吉·托马斯(

angie thomas)

的仇恨,你给学生的仇恨

是添加本文的驱动力

这为学生提供了一种具体的

方式 他们致力于将他们

对种族和种族主义的研究

变成交流 重要的是让学生

有机会采取

有意义的步骤反对种族主义,

因为了解种族主义有时

会让学生感到绝望

或不知所措,帮助学生看到

自己的

力量,并鼓励他们认识

到自己有

能力在 世界

可以减轻

学生

们在加深

对我国长期的制度性种族主义

和白人至上主义历史的理解时感到的一些愤世嫉俗和沮丧情绪,这

使我提出了

关于反种族主义工作和教育的最终建议

,也使我回到 这个

演讲从哪里

开始 我课堂上最重要的期望

自己想想老师可能是错的

这个想法对于

白人老师在

以白人为主的学校从事反种族主义工作尤其重要

学生尤其是有色人种学生

需要感到安全 当我

犯错时,

他们需要知道他们可以坚持 我

负责并

在我的行为造成有害

影响时向我指出 作为教师,我们

邀请学生积极

参与我们的反种族主义工作也很重要

学生的学习不应局限于

课堂 需要为学生提供

有机会

在他们的学校

和更大的社区中在反种族主义行动中发挥积极作用 我希望

你能考虑

在你自己的实践中继续深化和扩大反种族主义教学的

方法

我们将在此过程中犯错误,

但如果我们

在种族主义面前保持沉默,我们将

同谋延续一个

对我们的学生有害的制度,

正如埃利威塞尔所说,我们必须始终站在

一边,让我们站在

真理一边让 我们站在包容一边

让我们站在正义一边,

因为公平对

你很重要